9.89 mi
Italian
307 Old Country Rd, Carle Place, NY, 11514
Not Available Now (Available Sat 12:00 PM - 10:30 PM)
Cafe Formaggio
Ready to try some of the best Italian in Carle Place? Then it's time to order from Cafe Formaggio. Looking to find the cheapest way to order Cafe Formaggio? Choose the most affordable delivery option listed on this page. Their experience cooking up real Italian is almost unmatched in Carle Place. And you can be enjoying it from the comfort of home in no time at all. Order Cafe Formaggio delivery today!
Online Ordering Options
(See pickup options)Menu
- Postmates
Antipasti - Appetizers
Baked Clams Oreganata
$11.59
Calamari Fritti
Golden fried calamari served with a side of homemade marinara or fra diavolo sauce.
$14.75
Mussels & Clams Possillipo
Your choice of cultivated mussels or clams steamed and seasoned in a white wine garlic or marinara sauce.
$14.75
Hot Antipasto
Serves 2. a combination of baked clams, fried capellini, shrimp oreganata, mozzarella sticks and eggplant rollatini.
$17.89
Portabella
A layered tower of fresh mozzarella, marinated portobello mushrooms, red ripened tomato and basil, then drizzled with a tasty pesto and balsamic reduction.
$14.75
Fried Zucchini Sticks
$11.59
Grilled Artichoke Hearts
Grilled hearts topped with shaved pecorino cheese.
$11.59
Italian Spring Rolls
Fresh sausage meat sauteed with broccoli rabe, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella wrapped in a light spring roll.
$14.75
Cold Antipasto
Marinated artichoke hears, fresh mozzarella knots, fresh roasted peppers, prosciutto and fresh auribella cheese.
$15.79
Calamari Arrabiata
Golden fried calamari tossed with hot cherry peppers, roasted garlic and marinara sauce.
$15.79
Grilled Calamari & Shrimp
Grilled whole tube calamari and jumbo shrimp topped with rosemary, fresh squeezed lemon and olive oil.
$15.79
Mozzarella Fresca
Fresh mozzarella with vine-ripened tomatoes and roasted red peppers drizzled with extra virgin olive oil and balsamic vinegar.
$13.69
Capellini Cakes
3 pieces. Angel hair pasta combined with fresh ricotta, diced ham and Formaggio golden fried to perfection.
$13.69
Stuffed Artichoke
Fresh artichoke stuffed with toasted bread crumbs, plum tomatoes, formaggio and Italian herbs.
$13.69
Meatball Sliders
Our own homemade beef, pork and veal meatballs served on a fresh garlic roll or in a puff pastry dough, topped with a lite tomato sauce and shaved parmesan cheese.
$13.69
Zucchini Linguine
Linguine shaped zucchini sauteed with garlic in our famous pomodoro sauce.
$13.69
Antipasti - Gluten Free Appetizers
Baked Clams Oreganata
$12.65
Mussels & Clams Possillipo
Your choice of clams or cultivated mussels, steamed and seasoned in a white wine garlic or marinara sauce.
$14.75
Portabella
A layered tower of fresh mozzarella, marinated portobello mushroom, red ripened tomato and basil, drizzled with a tasty pesto and balsamic reduction.
$14.75
Grilled Artichoke Heart
Grilled hearts topped with shaved pecorino cheese.
$11.59
Pizza Margherita
Plum tomato basil sauce with homemade fresh mozzarella and a touch of olive oil.
$15.79
Calamari Fritti
Golden fried calamari served with a side of homemade marinara or fra diavolo sauce.
$16.85
Calamari Arrabiata
Golden fried calamari tossed with hot cherry peppers and roasted garlic in our famous pomodoro sauce.
$17.89
Cappellin Cakes
3 pieces. Angel hair pasta combined with fresh ricotta, diced ham, and Formaggio golden fried to perfection.
$15.79
Grilled Calamari & Shrimp
Whole tube calamari and jumbo shrimp grilled and topped with rosemary, fresh squeezed lemon and olive oil.
$15.79
Mozzarella Fresca
Fresh mozzarella with vine-ripened tomatoes and roasted red peppers drizzled with virgin olive oil and balsamic vinegar.
$13.69
Meatballs
2 pieces. Our famous meatballs made with gluten-free bread crumbs.
$9.49
Mini Rice Balls
3 pieces. Rice and parmesan cheese with seasonings, breaded and golden fried.
$9.49
Formaggio Wedges
Golden fried mozzarella wedges.
$11.59
Fried Zucchini Sticks
$13.69
Zucchini Linguini
Linguini shaped zucchini sauteed with garlic in our famous Pomodoro sauce.
$13.69
Stuffed Artichoke
Fresh artichoke stuffed with toasted bread crumbs, plum tomatoes, formaggio and Italian herbs.
$15.79
Appetizers Special - Daily Specials
Shrimp Crostini
Jumbo shrimp scampi served with chopped tomato and spinach over garlic crostini bread.
$15.79
Fried Burrata
Fried burrata served with arugula, roasted tomato and prosciutto.
$12.65
Lentil Soup
Lentil beans, celery, onions, and carrots in a vegetable broth with spinach and ditalini pasta.
$9.49
Zuppe - Soup
Pasta Fagioli Soup
White cannellini beans with pasta in a light plum tomato broth.
$8.44
Minestrone Soup
Assorted vegetables in a plum tomato broth.
$8.44
Stracciatella Romano Soup
Spinach, egg whites and chopped tomato in a savory chicken broth.
$8.44
Escarole & Beans Soup
Escarole and white cannellini beans with a touch of plum tomato in a savory broth.
$8.44
Tortellini In Brodo Soup
Cheese tortellini in a light chicken broth.
$8.44
Insalate - Salad
Classic Caesar Insalata
Romaine hearts with our homemade dressing topped with shaved formaggio.
$13.69
Formaggio Insalata
Romaine hearts, red onions, diced fresh mozzarella, cucumbers, black olives, tomatoes, and flame roasted peppers in a balsamic reduction.
$14.75
Antipasto Salad
Crisp chopped romaine lettuce with salami, provolone, roasted peppers and mushrooms in a red wine vinaigrette.
$14.75
Mango Salad
Romaine hearts, radicchio, endive, grape tomatoes, mesclun mix, walnuts, mango with a white balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
$14.75
House Salad
Iceberg lettuce, carrots, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers and olives served with our red wine vinaigrette.
$11.59
Beets Salad
Spinach salad topped with onions, tomatoes, avocado, feta cheese and beets in a balsamic dressing.
$14.75
Insalata Fagioli
Crisp roamine heart, grape tomatoes, red onions, red and white kidney beans, chick peas in a creamy Italian dressing.
$14.75
Insalata Buenavista
Spring mix greens topped with sliced apples, fresh mozzarella and caramelized walnuts, served with our honey mustard vinaigrette dressing.
$14.75
Insalata Nuova
Mixed greens, gorgonzola, diced mozzarella, fried goat cheese, roasted peppers and diced tomato with pesto and honey mustard vinaigrette dressing.
$14.75
Insalata Pera
Mixed mesclun greens topped with poached pears, crumbled bleu cheese and caramelized walnuts infused with our balsamic reduction.
$14.75
Pasta
Linguine Con Vongole - Red & White Pasta
Manila clams served in a marinara plum tomato sauce or garlic and virgin olive oil broth over linguine.
$22.15
Pappardelle Ragu Pasta
Fresh homemade pappardelle pasta topped with our old fashioned ragu sauce mixed with slow cooked beef Braciole.
$24.25
Cavatelli Con Cime Pasta
Cavatelli pasta, broccoli rabe, sweet Italian sausage and sundried tomatoes in a garlic and oil brodino.
$24.25
Rigatoni Alla Vodka Pasta
Imported prosciutto sauteed in a creamy pink vodka sauce.
$22.15
Rigatoni Filetto Pomodoro Pasta
Fresh plum garden tomato sauce with basil.
$24.25
Penne Madeira Pasta
Penne pasta tossed with grilled chicken strips and cubed homemade mozzarella, sauteed in a madiera wine fresh diced plum tomato brown sauce.
$23.19
Ravioli Alla Verde Pasta
Fresh homemade cheese filled ravioli in a spinach cream sauce.
$20.00
Lasagna Al Forno Pasta
Homemade pasta with parmesan cheese, mozzarella cheese, sausage and meat sauce.
$21.09
Aqua Pazza Pasta
Linguine with mussels, littleneck clams, calamari and shrimp in a filetto sauce topped with fresh basil.
$29.49
Tortellini Davinci Pasta
Fresh tortellini pasta with baby shrimp and mushrooms in a sherry pink sauce.
$26.35
Rigatoni Fiorentina Pasta
Rigatoni pasta tossed with grilled chicken strips, spinach and melted mozzarella, sauteed in a creamy pink sauce.
$24.25
Tortellini Ventura Pasta
Homemade tortellini pasta with sauteed chicken in a vodka sauce topped with a spoonful of mascarpone cheese.
$26.35
Capellini Stella Di Mare Pasta
Shrimp, scallops, and calamari in a marinara plum tomato sauce or fra diavolo sauce.
$27.39
Cavatelli Tre Funghi Pasta
Homemade pasta and grilled chicken with portabella, shitake and button mushrooms in a light brown marsala wine sauce with caramelized onions.
$23.19
Gnocchi Cotti Pasta
Gnocchi smothered in our signature creamy roasted pepper pesto with breaded chicken and sundried tomatoes.
$24.25
Penne E Gamber Pasta
Penne pasta tossed with fresh shrimp, broccoli florets and sundried tomatoes sauteed in a light garlic herbed brodino.
$25.29
Whole Wheat Penne Primavera Pasta
Assorted seasonal vegetables in your choice of a light garlic and oil or plum tomato sauce.
$21.09
Ravioli Gratinate Pasta
Homemade cheese-filled ravioli with meat sauce or tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
$22.15
Shrimp Marinara Pasta
Fresh shrimp served in a spicy fra diavolo sauce or a mild marinara plum tomato sauce over linguine.
$24.25
Gnocchi Calatafini Pasta
Our famous filet to di pomodoro sauce sautéed with sicilian eggplant and topped with fresh ricotta.
$22.15
Tortellini Caprese Pasta
Fresh tortellini pasta made with garlic and oil, fresh tomatoes, basil and fresh mozzarella.
$24.25
Cavatelli Salmone Pasta
Fresh salmon diced and sauteed in a light cream pink sauce with cherry tomatoes and fresh peas.
$27.39
Pasta - Gluten Free
Spaghetti Con Vongole Red & White Pasta
Manila clams served in a marinara plum tomato sauce or garlic and virgin olive oil broth over spaghetti.
$25.29
Gnocchi Ragu Pasta
Fresh homemade gnocchi pasta topped with old fashioned ragu sauce mixed with slow cooked beef Braciole.
$27.39
Penne Con Cime Pasta
Penne pasta, broccoli rabe, sweet Italian sausage and sundried tomatoes sauteed in a garlic and oil brodino.
$27.39
Penne Alla Vodka Pasta
Imported prosciutto sauteed in a creamy pink vodka sauce.
$23.19
Penne Filetto Pomodoro Pasta
Fresh plum garden tomato sauce with basil.
$23.19
Penne Filetto Pomodoro Pasta
Served with 2 meatballs.
$27.39
Penne Madeira Pasta
Penne pasta tossed with grilled chicken strips, cubed homemade mozzarella, sauteed in a madiera wine fresh diced plum tomato brown sauce.
$26.35
Ravioli Alla Verde Pasta
Fresh homemade cheese filled ravioli in a spinach cream sauce.
$24.25
Aqua Pazza Pasta
Spaghetti with mussels, littleneck clams, calamari, and shrimp in a filetto sauce topped with fresh basil.
$31.59
Penne Fiorentina Pasta
Penne pasta tossed with grilled chicken strips, spinach and melted mozzarella, sauteed in a creamy pink sauce.
$26.35
Penne Caprese Pasta
Penne pasta made with garlic and oil, fresh tomatoes, basil and fresh mozzarella.
$26.35
Penne Ventura Pasta
Penne pasta sauteed chicken in a vodka sauce topped with a spoonful of mascarpone cheese.
$27.39
Spaghetti Stella Di Mare Pasta
Shrimp, scallops and calamari in a marinara plum tomato sauce or fra diavolo sauce.
$30.55
Penne Tre Funghi Pasta
Penne pasta and grilled chicken with portobello, shiitake and button mushrooms in a light brown marsala wine sauce with caramelized onions.
$26.35
Gnocchi Cotti Pasta
Gnocchi smothered in our signature creamy roasted pepper pesto with breaded chicken and sundried tomatoes.
$27.39
Penne E Gamberi Pasta
Penne pasta tossed with fresh shrimp, broccoli florets and sundried tomatoes sauteed in a light garlic herbed brodino.
$28.45
Penne Primavera Pasta
Assorted seasonal vegetables in your choice of a light garlic and oil or plum tomato sauce.
$24.25
Ravioli Gratinate Pasta
Homemade cheese-filled ravioli with meat sauce or tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
$26.35
Shrimp Marinara Pasta
Fresh shrimp served in a spicy fra diavolo sauce or a mild marinara plum tomato sauce over spaghetti.
$27.39
Gnocchi Calatafini Pasta
Our famous filetto di pomodoro sauce sauteed with sicilian eggplant and a ricotta salata garnish.
$25.29
Penne Davinci Pasta
Penne pasta with baby shrimp and mushrooms in a sherry pink sauce.
$29.49
Penne Salmone Pasta
Fresh salmon diced and sauteed in a light cream pink sauce with cherry tomatoes and fresh peas.
$29.49
Entrees Special - Daily Specials
Stuffed Chicken Breast
Roasted chicken breast stuffed with prosciutto and mozzarella served over carrots and celery in a white wine sauce.
$26.35
St. Peter's Fish Picatta
Tilapia sauteed in a lemon butter sauce served with capers and artichoke over a bed of linguini pasta.
$26.35
Lobster Fra Diavlo
One pound of lobster served with clams over a bed of linguine in our spicy fra diavlo sauce.
$36.85
Bone In Veal Chop
Pan seared bone-in veal chop encrusted with fresh peppercorns topped with a sherry wine cream sauce. Served with spinach and garlic mashed potato.
$44.25
Mahi Mahi
Pan seared mahi mahi served over sweet chard, red onions, and roasted tomatoes with an orange honey vinegar glaze.
$33.69
Entrees
Gamberoni Risotto
Grilled marinated basil shrimp over a vegetable risotto in a scampi sauce.
$27.39
Limoncello Style
Pan seared filet of sole or jumbo shrimp served over a limoncello liqueur risotto mixed with spinach and mushrooms.
$27.39
Oreganata Style
Baked salmon, jumbo shrimp or filet of sole with seasoned breadcrumbs served over assorted sauteed vegetables.
$28.45
Salmon Trapani
Caramelized walnut encrusted norwegian salmon topped in our savory honey dijon sauce.
$29.49
Shrimp Monalisa
Breaded jumbo shrimp pan seared and topped with fresh mozzarella cheese simmered in a fresh mushroom marsala wine sauce.
$27.39
Chicken Carolina
Fresh battered breast of chicken topped with imported prosciutto, broccoli and melted mozzarella cheese in a garlic, white wine sauce.
$26.35
Chicken Balsamico
Tender pieces of chicken sauteed with carrots and baby string beans in a balsamic demi-glaze sauce served over garlic mashed potatoes.
$24.25
Chicken Scarpariello
Chicken breast, sausage, potatoes, and peppers in a white wine, garlic scarpariello sauce.
$26.35
Chicken Rollade
Stuffed with a spinach ricotta, and topped with melted mozzarella over a bed of mashed potatoes in a brown madeira wine sauce.
$26.35
Eggplant Parmigiana
Fresh battered eggplant baked with homemade tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.
$21.09
Eggplant Rollatini
Fresh battered eggplant rolled with seasoned ricotta, baked with a homemade tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.
$21.09
Chicken Primavera
Fresh grilled breast of chicken marinated in balsamic vinegar and imported seasonings, topped with a medley of sauteed fresh vegetables in a garlic & oil sauce.
$26.35
Grilled Chicken Pillardo
Topped with sauteed broccoli rabe and fresh mozzarella.
$26.35
Marinated Skirt Steak
Tender choice skirt steak, grilled to perfection, served over a bed of garlic mashed potatoes.
$32.65
Cedar Plank Salmon
Fresh salmon grilled on a cedar plank, topped with a balsamic glaze and served with sauteed broccoli and roasted potatoes.
$32.65
Veal Chop Valencia
Pan seared and baked, encrusted in caramelized almonds and walnuts served with a madiera demi-glaze, roasted potatoes and string beans.
$43.19
Chicken Cacciatore
Boneless pieces of chicken breast cooked with fresh tomatoes, onions, carrots, celery and mushrooms with a touch of marsala wine.
$25.29
Braised Short Ribs
Boneless beef ribs slow cooked to perfection served with whipped mashed potatoes and sauteed vegetables.
$30.55
St. Peters Fish Oreganata
Baked with seasoned bread crumbs and served with sauteed vegetables and roasted potatoes.
$26.35
Sorrentino
Your choice of veal or chicken sauteed and layered with imported prosciutto, golden fried eggplant and topped with fresh homemade mozzarella in a light shallot sherry wine sauce.
$25.29
Marsala
Tender medallions of your choice of veal or chicken sauteed in a classic marsala wine sauce with garden fresh mushrooms.
$25.29
Franchese
Fresh battered medallions of your choice of veal or chicken sauteed in a white wine, lemon butter sauce.
$27.39
Parmigiana
Tender slices of veal or chicken, golden fried and smothered with homemade pomodoro sauce and topped with fresh mozzarella.
$25.29
Picatta
Medallions of veal or chicken simmered with artichoke hearts & capers in a white wine lemon basil sauce.
$25.29
Pizzaiola
Tender medallions of veal or chicken sauteed in a sherry wine plum tomato sauce with peppers, onions and fresh mushrooms.
$25.29
Milanese
Golden fried veal or chicken covered with baby arugula, red onion & tomatoes.
$25.29
Entrees - Gluten Free
Gamberoni Risotto
Grilled marinated basil shrimp over a vegetable risotto in a scampi sauce.
$27.39
Limoncello Style
Pan seared filet of sole or jumbo shrimp served over a limoncello liqueur risotto mixed with spinach and mushrooms.
$30.55
Oreganata Style
Baked salmon, jumbo shrimp or filet of sole with seasoned bread crumbs served over assorted sauteed vegetables and potato.
$30.55
Salmon Trapani
Caramelized walnut encrusted norwegian salmon topped in our savory honey dijon sauce.
$30.55
Chicken Carolina
Fresh battered breast of chicken topped with imported prosciutto, broccoli and melted mozzarella cheese in a garlic, white wine sauce.
$31.59
Chicken Balsamico
Tender pieces of chicken sauteed with carrots and baby string beans in a balsamic demi-glaze sauce served over garlic mashed potatoes.
$27.39
Chicken Scarpariello
Chicken breast, sausage, potatoes, and peppers in a white wine, garlic scarpriello sauce.
$28.45
Chicken Rollade
Stuffed with a spinach ricotta topped with melted mozzarella over a bed of mashed potatoes in a brown madeira wine sauce.
$29.49
Eggplant Parmigiana
Fresh battered eggplant baked with homemade tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.
$24.25
Eggplant Rollatini
Fresh battered eggplant rolled with seasoned fresh ricotta, baked with a homemade tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.
$23.19
Chicken Primavera
Fresh grilled breast of chicken marinated in balsamic vinegar and imported seasonings, topped with a medley of sauteed fresh vegetables in a garlic and oil sauce.
$26.35
Grilled Chicken Pillardo
Topped with sauteed broccoli rabe and fresh mozzarella.
$26.35
Marinated Skirt Steak
Tender choice skirt steak, grilled to perfection, served over a bed of garlic mashed potatoes.
$32.65
Shrimp Monalisa
Breaded jumbo shrimp pan seared and topped with fresh mozzarella cheese simmered in a fresh mushroom marsala wine sauce.
$30.55
Cedar Plank Salmon
Fresh salmon grilled on a cedar plank, topped with a balsamic glaze and served with sauteed broccoli and roasted potatoes.
$32.65
Veal Chop Valencia
Pan seared and baked, encrusted in caramelized almonds and walnuts served with a madiera demi-glaze and roasted potatoes and string beans.
$43.19
Chicken Cacciatore
Boneless pieces of chicken breast cooked with fresh tomatoes, onions, carrots, celery and mushrooms with a touch of marsala wine.
$28.45
Braised Short Ribs
Boneless beef ribs slow cooked to perfection served with whipped mashed potatoes and sauteed vegetables.
$30.55
St. Peters Fish Oreganata
Baked with seasoned breadcrumbs and served with sauteed vegetables and roasted potatoes.
$27.39
Sorrentino
Your choice of veal or chicken sauteed and layered with imported prosciutto, golden fried eggplant and topped with fresh homemade mozzarella in a light shallot sherry wine sauce.
$27.39
Marsala
Tender medallions of your choice of veal or chicken sauteed in a classic marsala wine sauce with garden fresh mushrooms.
$27.39
Francese
Fresh battered medallions of your choice of veal or chicken sauteed in a white wine, lemon butter sauce.
$27.39
Parmigiana
Tender slices of veal or chicken, golden fried and smothered with homemade pomodoro sauce and topped with fresh mozzarella.
$27.39
Piccata
Medallions of veal or chicken simmered with artichoke hearts and capers in a white wine lemon basil sauce.
$27.39
Pizzaiola
Tender medallions of veal or chicken sauteed in a sherry wine plum tomato sauce with peppers, onions and fresh mushrooms.
$27.39
Milanese
Golden fried veal or chicken covered with baby arugula, red onion and tomatoes.
$27.39
Prix Fixe
Prix Fixe
$34.69
Side Orders
Broccoli Rabe
$9.49
Broccoli
$8.44
Escarole
$8.44
Penne & Capellini
With filetto, alla vodka, bolognese, garlic, and oil Pomodoro or butter sauce.
$14.75
Meatballs
2 pieces.
$7.39
Side Orders - Gluten Free
Broccoli Rabe
$9.49
Broccoli
$8.44
Escarole
$8.44
Penne & Spaghetti
With filetto, alla vodka, bolognese, garlic and oil, Pomodoro or butter sauce.
$11.59
Desserts Special - Daily Specials
Homemade Oreo Zeppoles
$11.59
Gluten Free Cheese Cake
$8.44
Gluten Free Red Velvet
$8.44
Gluten Free Crumb Cake
$8.44
Last updated December 27, 2019
PostmatesNot Delivering: Outside of delivery range
$0.00
Est. Fee
61 minEst. Time