2.90 mi
Sandwiches
Burgers
American
4221 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY, 10308
Fri 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Portobello Cafe
Order from Portobello Cafe to enjoy some of the best Burgers in Staten Island. Looking to find the cheapest way to order Portobello Cafe? Choose the most affordable delivery option listed here. Because they deliver in Staten Island, you can enjoy Portobello Cafe in the comfort of your own home. Don’t wait another day to treat yourself to their delicious Burgers! Check out the full Portobello Cafe menu below.
Online Ordering Options
(See pickup options)Postmatesbest deal
$3.99
Est. Fee
45 minEst. Time
Menu
- Postmates
Starters
1/2 Dozen Baked Clams
Littleneck clams stuffed with oreganata breadcrumbs and toasted to a golden brown. Finished with a white wine compound butter.
$8.94
Large Fried Calamari
Served with a choice of zesty basil tomato sauce, a spicy Asian cherry pepper sauce or a tangy buffalo-style and cayenne pepper sauce.
$14.95
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
5 jumbo shrimp served with homemade cocktail sauce.
$14.95
Rock Shrimp Tempura
Tender baby rock shrimp coated in tempura cooked to a golden brown finished with a cayenne peppers remoulade.
$13.95
Mom's Stuffed Artichoke
A jumbo artichoke stuffed with garlic Parmesan infused bread crumbs.
$14.95
Seasonal Stuffed Portobello Mushroom
A large grilled portobello mushroom topped with baby spinach, grape tomatoes, imported brie and bacon stuffing. Served over baby field greens and finished with a drizzle of black truffle essence.
$12.95
Sicilian-Style Rice Balls
6 4-cheese rice balls stuffed with chopped meat and peas.
$10.95
Eggplant Rollatini
Sliced eggplant fried to a golden brown, stuffed with fresh ricotta cheese and fresh mozzarella and finished with a zesty tomato basil sauce.
$9.94
Mozzarella en Carrozza
$10.95
Italian Egg Rolls
6 pieces. Parmesan risotto, broccoli rabe and sun-dried tomatoes served in a crisp egg roll shell. Served with a side of tomato basil dipping sauce.
$10.95
Grilled Vegetable Napolean
Grilled portobello mushroom topped with grilled zucchini, grilled yellow squash, garlic infused wilted baby spinach and sweet roasted peppers. Finished with a drizzle of fine herb infused extra virgin olive oil. Vegan.
$12.95
Parmesan Truffle Fries
Fresh yukon gold french fries tossed with a roasted garlic truffle remoulade and dusted with grated Parmesan cheese.
$11.95
Featured Seasonal Starters
Cinnamon Apple Cider Infused Pulled Pork Sliders
3-cinnamon apple cider infused pork topped with imported melted brie and a fresh cranberry compote served on brioche slider rolls.
$11.95
Parmesan Truffle Fries
Fresh cut french fries tossed in a Parmesan truffle aioli.
$11.95
Portobello Wings
8 jumbo wings fried to perfect crisp and tossed in your choice of roasted garlic lime sauce, Parmesan truffle sauce or honey teriyaki.
$10.95
Pistachio Crusted Lamb Chops
3-pistachio crusted lamb chops seared to perfection finished with a port wine demi-glace drizzle.
$14.95
Truffle Lobster Mac & Cheese
A creamy blend of imported brie, smoked gouda, provolone and Parmesan cheese infused with white truffle essence and succulent lobster meat served in a cast iron skillet and topped with toasted garlic infused bread crumbs.
$12.95
Truffle Infused Burrata
Over a bed of baby arugula, finished with a drizzle of balsamic reduction and white truffle essence served with roasted garlic croustini.
$12.95
Soups
Pasta e Fagioli Soup
Grandma's sunday pasta and white bean soup finished with grated Parmesan sauce.
$9.94
House Special Soup
Tortellini, spinach, portobello mushrooms and diced tomatoes in a light chicken broth.
$9.94
Puree of Butternut Squash Soup
A creamy puree of butternut squash and granny smith apples finished with a touch of cream.
$11.95
Classic Escarole & White Bean Soup
Slow cooked escarole and white bean soup infused with sweet Italian sausage.
$10.95
Salads
A Perfect Caesar Salad Large
Crisp romaine lettuce and homemade croutons tossed with homemade creamy Caesar dressing and finished with freshly grated reggiano cheese.
$10.95
Classic Wedge Salad
A wedge of iceberg lettuce topped with imported crumble bleu cheese, crisp candied bacon, diced tomatoes and diced red onions finished with a buttermilk blue cheese dressing.
$10.95
Large Mixed Field Greens Salad
Topped with cucumber, Kalamata olives, shoestring carrots, diced tomatoes and sliced red onions. Finished with a light balsamic vinaigrette.
$8.94
Seasonal Kale Salad
Baby kale tossed with diced apples, crumbled imported bleu cheese, toasted walnuts and dried cranberries finished with an orange cinnamon vinaigrette.
$10.95
Heroes & Wraps
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
A chicken breast fried to golden brown smothered with fresh mozzarella and tomato basil sauce. Served with french fries.
$12.95
Veal Parmigana Hero
Topped with fresh mozzarella and a zesty tomato sauce. Served with french fries.
$13.95
Grilled Portobello Hero
Portobello mushroom, spinach and roasted peppers finished with a sweet balsamic reduction. Served with french fries.
$11.95
Prosciutto & Mozzarella
Prosciutto and fresh mozzarella on sourdough drizzled with pesto sauce. Served with french fries.
$15.95
Grilled Skirt Steak Hero
Grilled skirt steak topped with sauteed onions, mushrooms and melted provolone cheese. Served with french fries.
$16.50
Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Hero
Sweet Italian sausage and garlic infused sauteed broccoli rabe. Served with french fries.
$14.95
Classic Chicken Melt
Panko crusted chicken breast topped with crisp bacon and melted provolone with our chef's own JD BBQ sauce. Served with french fries.
$14.95
Captain Crunch Chicken Wrap
Captain crunch crusted chicken, crisp bacon and American cheese topped with JD BBQ sauce in a flour tortilla. Served with french fries.
$13.95
Grilled Chicken Balsamic Wrap
Grilled chicken breast, sweet roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella finished with a sweet balsamic reduction and extra virgin olive oil. Served with french fries.
$14.95
Meatball Parmigiana Hero
Kobe beef meatballs smothered with homemade fresh mozzarella and tomato basil sauce. Served with french fries.
$11.95
Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap
Grilled chicken breast with crisp romaine lettuce and creamy Caesar dressing. Served with french fries.
$12.95
Sriracha Infused Grilled Shrimp Wrap
Tender jumbo shrimp grilled to perfection topped with a crisp lettuce, tomato and sliced red onions, finished with a sriracha chile mayo and wrapped in a flour tortilla. Served with french fries.
$14.95
Pastabilities
Pasta Primavera
Mixed seasonal vegetables in a roasted garlic aioli served over a bed of angel hair pasta.
$19.95
Penne Vodka Pasta
Creamy pink sauce with prosciutto and grated Parmesan cheese tossed with penne pasta.
$19.95
Baked Meat & Cheese Lasagna Pasta
Finished with a zesty tomato basil sauce.
$18.95
Cheese Ravioli Bolognese Pasta
$18.95
Uncle Tony's Prosciutto Sauce Pasta
Sauteed prosciutto and caramelized onions in a chunky tomato basil sauce over penne.
$19.95
Sauteed Chicken Scampi Pasta
Sauteed chicken breast, spinach and sun-dried tomatoes in a garlic scampi sauce over linguini pasta.
$21.95
Chicken Fettuccini Alfredo Pasta
Sauteed chicken breast, wilted spinach and sweet sun-dried tomatoes tossed with fresh fettuccini and finished with a traditional creamy Alfredo sauce.
$23.95
Sauteed Chicken & Artichoke Hearts Pasta
Sauteed chicken breast, artichoke hearts and sun-dried tomatoes tossed with whole wheat penne pasta and finished with garlic white sauce.
$23.95
Tortellini Carbonara Pasta
A rich creamy Parmesan cheese sauce tossed with sweet peas and prosciutto.
$19.95
18th Avenue Feast Pasta
Sauteed sweet Italian sausage and broccoli rabe in a garlic scampi sauce served over a bed of rigatoni.
$23.95
Fresh Lobster Ravioli Pasta
Tossed with grape tomatoes and asparagus and finished with a pink cognac cream sauce.
$25.95
House Pasta
Sauteed shiitake mushrooms, caramelized onions sun-dried tomatoes, garlic, prosciutto and peas in a creamy brown cognac sauce over rigatoni pasta.
$20.95
Mom's Sunday Dinner Pasta
Homemade kobe beef meatballs, sweet Italian sausage and beef braciole in gravy over a bed of rigatoni topped with dollops of ricotta cheese.
$27.95
Classic Shrimp Sauce Pasta
A fresh tomato basil sauce infused with shrimp and served over penne pasta.
$21.95
Rigatoni Pasta & Shrimp
Tender jumbo shrimp and rigatoni pasta baked in a cognac tomato cream sauce.
$24.95
Linguini Clam Sauce Pasta
Mouth-watering baby vongole clams in red or white sauce.
$21.95
Sauteed PEI Mussels Pasta
Sauteed cultivated black mussels in a tomato basil sauce over a bed of angel hair pasta.
$21.95
Calamari Fra Diavolo Pasta
Sauteed calamari in a spicy fra diavolo sauce over a bed of linguini.
$20.95
Seafood Fra Diavolo Pasta
A medley of tender calamari, PEI mussels, vongole clams and jumbo shrimp tossed in a spicy tomato basil sauce and served over a bed of linguini.
$28.95
Cippino Pasta
Sauteed baby clams, PEI mussels and jumbo shrimp in a zesty tomato basil sauce served over angel hair pasta.
$25.95
Farfalle Salmon Pasta
Farfalle pasta tossed with chunks of fresh salmon, sweet peas and sliced white mushrooms finished with a light cream sauce.
$23.95
Gourmet Pizzas
Margherita Pie Pizza
House-made fresh mozzarella, imported plum tomatoes, fresh basil and grated Parmesan. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$17.00
The Siciliano Pie Pizza
House-made fresh mozzarella topped with a sweet caramelized red onion infused marinara sauce and finished with toasted oreganata breadcrumbs. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$19.00
Classic Vodka Pie Pizza
House-made fresh mozzarella topped with our creamy vodka sauce. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$20.00
Captain Crunch Chicken Pie Pizza
Layers of house-made fresh mozzarella, American cheese, diced captain crunch chicken, caramelized bacon finished with a drizzle of JD BBQ. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$27.00
Classic White Pie Pizza
Roasted garlic infused ricotta, house-made fresh mozzarella and grated Parmesan. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$19.00
Truffle Mania Pie Pizza
House-made fresh mozzarella, imported goat cheese béchamel, caramelized shallots, toasted pinioli nuts, parma prosciutto shavings, bing cherries and baby arugula finished with white truffle essence. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$25.00
The Ultimate Pepperoni Pie Pizza
A classic margarita pie smothered with layers of fresh mozzarella and sliced pepperoni cups. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$20.00
Local Boys Special Pie Pizza
House-made fresh mozzarella, roasted garlic infused broccoli rabe, sun-dried tomatoes topped with dollops of imported burrata. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$27.00
Hotter Than Hell Pie Pizza
A classic margarita topped with sliced hot cherry peppers and fried chicken. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$24.00
Meat Lovers Pie Pizza
Shavings of slow cooked dry rubbed beef short ribs, pork butt and slab bacon drizzled with JD BBQ sauce and an aged cheddar cheese sauce topped with crispy fried shallot rings. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$29.00
Buffalo Chicken Pie Pizza
House-made fresh mozzarella topped with diced fried chicken finished with crumbled imported bleu cheese and a buttery cayenne pepper hot sauce. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$24.00
Clam up Pie Pizza
House-made fresh mozzarella, fresh clam sauce topped with oreganata breadcrumbs - red or white. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$22.00
Lobster Fondue Pie Pizza
A cheesy cognac infused lobster fondue topped with wilted baby spinach and sweet roasted peppers. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$29.00
Shrimp Fra Diablo Pie Pizza
A classic margherita topped with jumbo shrimp and a fra diablo tomato basil sauce. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$28.00
Holy Shiitake Pie Pizza
House-made fresh mozzarella, caramelized shallots and shiitake mushrooms in a butter wine buerre blanc. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$23.00
The Garden Pie Pizza
House made fresh mozzarella topped with blistered heirloom cherry tomato’s, caramelized red onion pedals and baby arugula finished with a drizzle of EVOO and sweet balsamic reduction. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$28.00
Caesar Salad Pie Pizza
A fresh tomato basil sauce topped with crisp romaine lettuce coated in our creamy Caesar dressing finished with imported Parmesan cheese shavings and home-made croutons. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$24.00
10" Cauliflower Pesto Pie Pizza
A cauliflower pizza crust topped with house-made fresh mozzarella and a creamy basil pesto finished with slow cooked apple wood smoked slab bacon - keto friendly. Fresh, made to order, delicious large pizza pie.
$17.00
Poultry
Mascarpone Chicken Breast
Sauteed chicken breast tossed with roasted peppers and portobello mushrooms. Served over Parmesan risotto, infused with sauteed baby spinach and finished with mascarpone demi glace.
$23.95
Chicken Franchaise
Sauteed chicken breast in a white wine lemon butter sauce.
$23.95
Seasonal Chicken Rollatini
An 8 oz chicken breast stuffed with bacon wrapped asparagus and imported brie roasted to perfection. Served over mashed red skin potatoes topped with fried shoe string carrots and finished with rosemary infused cream sauce.
$25.95
Da Best Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken breast fried to a golden brown smothered in homemade fresh mozzarella and our zesty tomato basil sauce.
$24.95
Tuscan Grilled Chicken
Tender herb-crusted grilled chicken breast topped with grilled portobello mushrooms, sweet red peppers and melted provolone cheese. Served over a warm orzo pasta salad and finished with a brandy-demi glace.
$23.95
Sauteed Chicken Portobello
Topped with a melody of wild mushrooms and sun-dried tomatoes in a cognac demi glace.
$24.95
Roasted Stuffed Chicken Breast
Boneless chicken breast stuffed with fresh smoked mozzarella and andouille sausage and served over Spanish-style risotto. Topped with crisp fried spinach and drizzled with a sun-dried tomato saffron cream sauce.
$25.95
Meats
Veal Sorrentino
Sauteed veal scallopini topped with eggplant, fresh mozzarella and prosciutto in a brown brandy sauce.
$25.95
Slow Cooked Beef Short Ribs
Tender slow cooked short ribs served over mashed red skin potatoes. Topped with fried shallot petals and finished with JD BBQ glaze.
$25.95
Land & Sea
A petite cut filet mignon and a 8 oz lobster tail roasted to perfection. Served with a drawn butter dipping sauce and sauteed spinach.
$39.95
Truffle Infused Grass Fed NY Strip Steak
A 12 oz truffle infused NY strip grilled to perfection served over mashed red skin potatoes and pencil asparagus.
$29.95
Bacon Wrapped Filet Mignon
A tender 8 oz filet mignon wrapped in bacon and roasted to perfection served over mashed red skin potatoes and topped with roasted garlic infused kale.
$32.95
Apple Cider Infused Pork Osso Bucco
Slow cooked apple cider infused pork osso bucco served with butternut squash risotto and roasted garlic infused kale topped with a fresh gremolata.
$25.95
Honey Glazed Double Cut Pork Chop
A double cut pork chop glazed with honey and topped with a cherry pepper cognac demi glace over sauteed broccoli rabe.
$23.95
Garlic Rosemary Crusted Rack of Lamb
6 tender baby lamb chops crusted with roasted garlic and rosemary served over mashed red skin potatoes and sauteed baby spinach.
$33.95
50/50 Burger
A 10 oz 50% apple wood smoked bacon and 50% filet mignon burger topped with candied bacon, smoked gouda, lettuce and tomato on a pretzel roll topped with beer battered onion rings served with a side of Parmesan truffle fries.
$28.95
Seafood
Walnut Crusted Salmon Fillet
Walnut crusted salmon fillet roasted to perfection served over butternut squash risotto and roasted garlic infused kale finished with a maple demi-glace.
$25.95
Butter Poached Lobster Tail
8 oz. Served over a creamy goat cheese polenta topped with roasted garlic infused kale finished with a drizzle of orange infused brown butter sauce.
$28.95
Lemon Pepper Infused Tilapia
Lemon pepper infused tilapia fillet pan seared to perfection served over sun-dried tomato rice pilaf and roasted garlic infused kale finished with a lemon caper brown butter sauce.
$23.95
Sundried Tomato Crusted Chilean Sea Bass
Served over a creamy goat cheese polenta and pencil asparagus finished with a drizzle of lemon infused brown butter sauce.
$29.95
Keto Friendly Menu
Bacon Spinach Cream Cheese Stuffed Portobello Mushroom
Low carb dishes.
$13.95
Avocado Fries
Avocado slices coated in an almond coconut flour and served with a sriracha mayo dipping sauce. Low carb dishes.
$11.95
Basil Pesto Spaghetti Squash
Basil pesto cream sauce over spaghetti squash topped with fried prosciutto crackles. Low carb dishes.
$17.95
Pistachio Crusted Lamb
Pistachio crusted lamb chops serves over cauliflower mashed and sauteed kale. Low carb dishes.
$34.95
Keto Bacon Wrapped Filet Mignon
Bacon wrapped filet mignon over cauliflower mashed and sauteed kale. Low carb dishes.
$31.95
10” Cauliflower Pesto Pizza Pie
A cauliflower pizza crust topped with house-made fresh mozzarella and a creamy basil pesto finished with slow cooked apple wood smoked slab bacon. Low carb dishes.
$17.00
Kid's Menu
Kids Captain Crunch Chicken Fingers
Our chef's own captain crunch coated chicken fingers fried to perfection served with french fries and our homemade JD BBQ dipping sauce.
$8.94
Kids Traditional Chicken Fingers
Panko crusted chicken fingers fried to a golden brown served with french fries.
$8.94
Kids Mini Penne Vodka
Penne pasta tossed in a pink cream sauce.
$8.94
Kids Mini Chicken Parmigiana
Mini version of "da best" chicken parmigiana smothered in fresh mozzarella and marinara sauce served with linguini.
$8.94
Kids Ravioli
Cheese ravioli marinara.
$8.94
Beverages - Soda
Coke
12 oz can.
$2.00
Diet Coke
12 oz can.
$2.00
Sprite
12 oz can.
$2.00
Desserts
NY Cheesecake
$8.94
Seasonal Fresh Fruit
$8.94
Tiramisu
Espresso soaked lady fingers topped with a light marscapone cheese mixture finished with Dutch cocoa.
$8.94
Nanny's Italian Cheesecake
Made with ricotta delicately textures with a hint of orange.
$8.94
Our Famous Fried Oreos
Fried to perfection and dusted with powdered sugar.
$7.95
Da Best Cannoli
$6.95
Last updated November 5, 2020
Postmatesbest deal
$3.99
Est. Fee
45 minEst. Time
View All Deals (2)
Place Order